Difference between revisions of "Doing your best to get rid of smudging in FFMPEG transcoding of RTSP streams"
From ZoneMinder Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Various Learnings from getting Zomeminder 1.28.1 working well on Ubuntu Server 14.04|<Home]] | [[Various Learnings from getting Zomeminder 1.28.1 working well on Ubuntu Server 14.04|<Home]] | ||
===Background=== | |||
All my cameras are Foscam HD cameras (1280x960) and support RTSP. Further , 4 out of my 5 cameras are connected via WiFi. | |||
Zone minder has many options to capture frames, but for Foscam cameras it boils down to: | |||
* Using the Foscam "snapshot2" URL to capture images instead of live streaming | |||
* Using RTSP URL | |||
* Using MJPEG URL (needs a configuration change to Foscam) | |||
I investigated all 3 options. | |||
* In terms of quality, Option 1 (image snapshot) is the best. No artifacts, no smudging nothing. The downside is there are a high amount of connection drops, even if I dropped the HD stream to 720p. | |||
* Foscam seems to only stream MJPEG as 640x480. That was not acceptable (and the quality of the stream seemed to have a lot of artifacting) | |||
* So really, the only option left was RTSP | |||
===RTSP via FFMPEG/VLC/Remote === | |||
Now that RTSP was the only viable option, there are 3 methods you can use (well, maybe 4, not sure if Curl supports RTSP - never tried) | |||
* You can use source type as FFMPEG, VLC or (a new addition with ZM 1.28) Remote | |||
====Source Type: Remote==== | |||
Based on [https://github.com/ZoneMinder/ZoneMinder/issues/734|this] issue in github | |||
===Smearing=== | ===Smearing=== |
Revision as of 11:29, 24 March 2015
Background
All my cameras are Foscam HD cameras (1280x960) and support RTSP. Further , 4 out of my 5 cameras are connected via WiFi. Zone minder has many options to capture frames, but for Foscam cameras it boils down to:
- Using the Foscam "snapshot2" URL to capture images instead of live streaming
- Using RTSP URL
- Using MJPEG URL (needs a configuration change to Foscam)
I investigated all 3 options.
- In terms of quality, Option 1 (image snapshot) is the best. No artifacts, no smudging nothing. The downside is there are a high amount of connection drops, even if I dropped the HD stream to 720p.
- Foscam seems to only stream MJPEG as 640x480. That was not acceptable (and the quality of the stream seemed to have a lot of artifacting)
- So really, the only option left was RTSP
RTSP via FFMPEG/VLC/Remote
Now that RTSP was the only viable option, there are 3 methods you can use (well, maybe 4, not sure if Curl supports RTSP - never tried)
- You can use source type as FFMPEG, VLC or (a new addition with ZM 1.28) Remote
Source Type: Remote
Based on [1] issue in github
Smearing
Once I had ZM up and running for a day or two, I started noticing a lot of frame "smearing". This is what I mean by smearing: